Competing with Manufacturers Overseas
In this year’s politically charged atmosphere, the issue of overseas competition for jobs and
merchandise contracts is on everyone’s minds. Jewelry manufacturing, like many industries, has
been dramatically affected by foreign competition. How can you compete? Is it just a matter of
time before designers in China and Thailand replace domestic brands altogether?
|
|
The answer is no. However, do not take this competition lightly.
New competitive forces mean that you must analyze your market
and adapt your business strategies accordingly in order to be successful.
One common technique used as a starting point for strategic analysis is a SWOT Analysis. SWOT stands
for Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats. The following article will include a SWOT
Analysis of overseas designers’ and domestic designers’ competitive positions, as well as a discussion
and interpretation of the results. This article does not include any secrets or magic business plans;
but, hopefully it will help you to organize your thoughts and further refine your business strategies.
Overseas Manufacturers Analysis
- Strengths – Inexpensive labor, low cost materials, ability to quickly produce mass
quantities, established distribution channels, negotiating power due to size.
- Weaknesses – No knowledge of local markets, wide range in quality, inability to customize,
no access to some materials, mediocre branding, easy availability often means less desirability, slow to
respond to trends, geographic distance from trade partners.
- Opportunities – Able to produce inexpensive designs for the mass market through volume
distribution channels. Can influence trends due to sheer magnitude of distribution.
- Threats – Proliferation of fellow overseas manufacturers means rapidly decreasing margins
and increasing competition in the same distribution channels. Larger production runs increase exposure
to risk due to high investments.
Domestic Designers Analysis
- Strengths – In depth knowledge of local markets, quality, rapid response to trends, ability to customize,
ability to offer personalized service, personal relationships with distribution channel members.
- Weaknesses – Costly labor, small size, less negotiating power in the supply chain, production speed.
- Opportunities – Ability to carve out niche market(s) in style or region through branding. Ability to
differentiate through service excellence. Ability to meet market demand for original pieces with more
cache than mass-produced designs. Even the largest retail franchises still like to offer designs from
small "boutique" designers to round out their selections.
- Threats – Overseas manufacturers are consuming mass market distribution channels. Proliferation of fellow
domestic designers in niche markets.
Discussion and Interpretation
First, you must recognize the limitations of your position realistically. A small domestic designer cannot
compete with overseas manufacturers on price alone. It is not sustainable in the long term. Materials and
labor are so much cheaper overseas that you would have to price yourself out of profits to compete.
When it comes to selling products, mass production factories have easier access to large scale retail buyers.
You will have to work harder to get their attention; and, once you have it, you will have less negotiating
power when writing contracts and sourcing materials.
That is not to say you should lose heart; which brings us to the second point: Leave mass production to the
mass producers. Let them have it! There is plenty of opportunity in the (often large) niches left unfulfilled
by these companies.
Mass merchandise is completely impersonal; it is one of the primary weaknesses of overseas suppliers. There
is a market for mass produced goods; but, it will always leave market share for companies that cater to clients
who want to define themselves by not buying exactly what everyone else has. This is especially true of fashion
items, like jewelry. You notice people’s jewelry when it stands out. Make your designs stand out.
You must identify your viable competitive advantages and leverage those into market position. What makes your
designs different? What makes your company different? How can you brand your goods to speak to consumers on
a personal level?
Jewelry is usually a sentimental purchase. I could dump out my (very large) jewelry box and tell you exactly when
and where I got each piece. Moreover, the vast bulk of the contents are very inexpensive items. Jewelry is bought
or given on special occasions or as souvenirs from memorable travels. People want to buy special pieces to
commemorate their special moments in life.
The contents of this analysis are largely common sense. As business people, designers must be aware of their own
positions and the relative positions of their competition. However, many designers do not follow through and use
this knowledge in their strategic planning. Moreover, many choose to ignore or underestimate competitive forces
only to succumb to a worthy adversary down the road. A SWOT Analysis is a useful tool to begin your business
strategy. Use the above analysis as a jumping off point by adding details specific to your business. With savvy
business management, those mass merchants should not slow you down a bit. Good luck!
|
|